Back to Blog

Claude Fable 5.2 at Medium Effort: The Same Tasks Solved for 72% Less, Still 2× Opus

2026-11-11·5 min read·CodeRouter Team

Disclosure: we build CodeRouter, a router for coding agents. For this test we called Claude Fable 5.2 directly through Anthropic's API, not through CodeRouter.

Yesterday we published Claude Fable 5.2 on 30 tasks from our coding-agent benchmark: at the API's default settings it solved the same tasks as Sonnet 5.5 and cost 8× as much as Opus 5.5. We noted one gap: the API default is high effort, while Claude Code defaults Fable to Medium.

So we ran the same 30 tasks again with one change, effort: medium. It solved the same 15 tasks as the high-effort run, for 72% less. It still cost 2.2× Opus.

The results

Same 30 tasks, same agent harness, same limits, one run. In the first run, six high-effort sessions were stopped by our budget for the run before they finished; this time all 30 finished. So the Medium-vs-High comparison uses the 24 tasks both runs completed, and the comparison with the other setups uses all 30. Costs are list prices.

Medium vs High, 24 tasks:

Setup Solved Cost per task Steps per task Output tokens per step
Fable 5.2, Medium 15 $0.436 8.6 601
Fable 5.2, High (API default) 15 $1.571 18.0 1,263

Medium vs the other setups, all 30 tasks (the others are the November 9 first run on the same tasks):

Setup Solved (of 30) Cost per task Cost per solved task
Claude Fable 5.2, Medium 17 $0.466 $0.822
All Claude Opus 5.5 18 $0.216 $0.360
All Claude Sonnet 5.5 17 $0.082 $0.144
CodeRouter default routing 15 $0.081 $0.163
All Claude Haiku 5.5 13 $0.010 $0.023

On 30 tasks, a completion rate has a wide interval (Fable Medium: 56.7%, 39–73%). We can't tell Fable, Opus and Sonnet apart on completion here. On cost, the gaps are clear.

Where the 72% went

Medium cut the cost two ways, about equally: Fable took half as many steps, and each step cost 42% less because it wrote and thought less and re-read a shorter conversation (24 tasks, per request unless noted):

Medium High Ratio
Steps per task 8.6 18.0 0.48×
Output tokens per step, thinking included 601 1,263 0.48×
Thinking tokens per step (estimated) 172 711 0.24×
Steps with a thinking block 54% 78%
Cache-read tokens per step 14,603 37,850 0.39×
Cost per step $0.051 $0.087 0.58×

Fewer steps also means a shorter conversation to re-read on each one, which is why cache reads per step fell too. No Medium response hit the 8,192-token output limit; ten High responses did.

Against Opus 5.5, Fable at Medium now takes fewer steps (8.6 vs 11.2), but each step costs 2.9× as much. Fable's input, output and cache-write prices are twice Opus's (cache reads cost the same), and it writes 1.6× the output per step.

What this means

How we ran it

Everything as in the first run: the same 30 tasks, mini-swe-agent 2.4.6 with its bash tool, 150 steps, $10 and 60 minutes per session, 60 seconds per command, max_tokens 8,192, containers with no network access (checked with a probe before the start), graded with swebench 5.0.2 and SWE-rebench's evaluation spec. The only change is output_config: {"effort": "medium"} on every request, sent directly to Anthropic's Messages API with a separate key. Every one of the 282 responses reported claude-fable-5-2. On the same machine, every task's upstream fix passed and an empty change failed. We wrote the plan down in a dated internal document before the run.

Limitations

The data

Download the summary JSON and a per-session CSV (30 rows: task, solved, cost, steps and tokens), next to the High-effort run and the 99-task results. No agent trajectories.

Try phase-aware routing on your own workload

One base URL for Claude Code, Cursor or Aider. Free trial, no credit card.

Start free trial

Get weekly AI cost optimization tips

Join developers cutting their agent bills